New York City Pizza

Donald Elam, II

-

July 13, 2024

We went there mid day, fast service and the food was so amazingly good. Definitely a must if you are in the area. And the staff was phenomenal. Thank you for a wonderful experience. Also, they are pet friendly. But please, keep your fur baby in a leash and make sure they are trained and well behaved.

Mike T

-

November 12, 2024

All the food here was good, got the Garlic Parmesan wings, Turkey and provolone sandwich, and the Sicilian style pizza. I’d come back here for sure.

Pam Bridges

-

June 18, 2024

Lunch today was a disaster. Our server was a young woman who was clueless about the menu. We asked for half and half tea and she brought out unsweetened. We asked if we could order spaghetti with meat sauce and explained that we didn’t want tomato sauce. She brought this orange sauce with meat in it along with ziti noodles. We ordered a ny slice of vegetarian pizza that was burned black on the bottom. When I complained, they brought me another slice with raw vegetables on it. As for the spaghetti with meat sauce, we got spaghetti with tomato sauce and a bowl of orange stuff with meat in it. Awful!!! What a waste of money the meal was. We would never go back.

Dmetri Smith

-

October 25, 2024

We came in as a party of 15 with 13 high school students and 2 adults. From jump, the staff was ready to feed us. The kitchen staff went into action, the server took our orders promptly, and the food came out quickly and was delicious. It’s obvious this establishment is a neighborhood fave as many people came in to grab takeout orders. And I love that you can get slices with whatever toppings you like. I was very pleased with our time here.

Fati Mosley

-

August 10, 2024

Pizza has amazing flavor. Medium pizza seems bigger than the pizzas from pizza chains. Staff are friendly and courteous. I'll come again next time we visit.