New York City Pizza

190 E Bay St #102, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

About New York City Pizza

3.9 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Elaina Peterson
    -
    May 26, 2025

    Don't be turned away by lower reviews because this place was fantastic! Not expecting this but we had some amazing food. They were out of stock of gluten free pasta, so we got a gluten free pizza which was pretty great. We got one of the best calzones we'd ever had, and the fettuccine Alfredo was far more tasty than I was expecting. Everything tasted homemade and fresh and flavorful! Our waiter was super friendly and professional and quick to get us what we needed. This place is great - give it a shot!

    Tracy Strevel
    -
    May 24, 2025

    Service was perfect. The waitress was attentive without smothering. Food was amazing! Mozzarella sticks bigger than a Twinkie and so delicious. The NY thin crust pizza was crispy around the edges and the toppings were so so delicious too. Chopped salad was so fresh and tasty. Highly recommended and great value for the amount of food.

    Donald Elam, II
    -
    July 13, 2024

    We went there mid day, fast service and the food was so amazingly good. Definitely a must if you are in the area. And the staff was phenomenal. Thank you for a wonderful experience. Also, they are pet friendly. But please, keep your fur baby in a leash and make sure they are trained and well behaved.

    Mike T
    -
    November 12, 2024

    All the food here was good, got the Garlic Parmesan wings, Turkey and provolone sandwich, and the Sicilian style pizza. I’d come back here for sure.

    Pam Bridges
    -
    June 18, 2024

    Lunch today was a disaster. Our server was a young woman who was clueless about the menu. We asked for half and half tea and she brought out unsweetened. We asked if we could order spaghetti with meat sauce and explained that we didn’t want tomato sauce. She brought this orange sauce with meat in it along with ziti noodles. We ordered a ny slice of vegetarian pizza that was burned black on the bottom. When I complained, they brought me another slice with raw vegetables on it. As for the spaghetti with meat sauce, we got spaghetti with tomato sauce and a bowl of orange stuff with meat in it. Awful!!! What a waste of money the meal was. We would never go back.

    New York City Pizza

    Our Address

    190 E Bay St #102, Charleston, SC 29401, USA

    ACTIVATE YOUR 7-DAY FREE TRIAL TO PROPEL SALES FORWARD

    Read More

    Add Your Business, It's FREE!

    Start getting more customers contacting your business with a free listing.